I've been on a major Disney kick for the past several weeks. Maybe it's due to the fact that I'm getting older and trying to recapture my youth, but I've watched several movies repeatedly that I loved as a child. One of the movies I've watched three or four times in the past two weeks is Lion King. And you know what I realized? Scar really isn't that bad of a guy.
Yes, he wanted to kill his brother and his nephew, and that is terrible. But, as far as villains go, Scar looked more like a bad guy than he actually ever was.
First, we see that Scar hated Simba when the little cub goes bouncing into his little area of Pride Rock talking nonstop about the fact that he's going to be king of Pride Rock. Now, if you were raised up as a child, wouldn't you be a bit peeved that some little runt is bouncing around what is essentially your living room bragging about the fact that you, in fact,
wont be king. Scar always thought that at some point he would be king after Mufasa got too old (or died).
Then you have the fact that Scar's main allies were the hyenas. Was this because he promised them land? Fortunes? Or did he just promise that the hyenas would "never go hungry again"? That's right... The hyenas were starving and always running out of food. Mufasa had banished them to a shadowed no-man's-land where nothing grew and they had to scavenge for food. Three hyenas were over the moon about the fact that scar brought them one partial leg of a zebra to eat. Isn't that a bit sad? They were starving and wanted nothing more than a leader that would at least give them a way to survive.
Lastly, Scar got blamed for winter. If Scar had the "formal" training needed in order to be king, he would have planned for the winter when herds moved on. He would have either had the pride move along with the other herds they relied on for food or he would have done something to make sure there was food that would last them through the winter. scar obviously did not plan for the winter. So, when the herds moved on
because of winter and the plants died
because of winter there was obviously a food shortage. And, apparently it is Scar's fault that winter hit the Pride Lands.
Yes, I know that Scar was a pretty screwed up guy. There had to be some sort of family issues in the pride when he was growing up with Mufasa. If there hadn't been some sort of family issues, would Mufasa have thought it was so funny at the idea that he would "make a lovely throw rug"? Out of all the Disney villains, Scar really is the one that is the one that looks more evil than he actually is.